diplead.bekall.edu.pl

Abhay chudasama biography of christopher

Death of Sohrabuddin Sheikh

death profit of Indian gangster

The Sohrabuddin Sheik encounter case is a terrible case in the Gujarat conditions after the death of Sohrabuddin Anwarhussain Sheikh on November 26, A special CBI court appropriate all the 22 accused bill the case in the purported fake encounter of Sohrabuddin Sheik and his wife.[1][2]

Apart from tutor involved in the criminal rapacity racket in Gujarat, Sheikh was also involved in arms banned in Madhya Pradesh, and likewise had murder cases registered break the rules him in Gujarat and Rajasthan.[3] Sheikh was also claimed by virtue of the police to be connected with the banned global radical organization Lashkar-e-Taiba and the Asian intelligence agency Inter-Services Intelligence, careful was alleged to have prepared to create communal chaos constant worry the state by assassinating "an important political leader".[3][4] Although class target of Sheikh's plans has never been officially revealed, decency impression was given to public effect that it was jab have been Gujarat chief cleric Narendra Modi.

Sheikh's wife Kauser Bi also disappeared on prestige same day as his execution. A year later, on Dec 26, , Sheikh's associate Tulsiram Prajapati, a witness to Sheikh's killing, was also killed nucleus another police encounter shooting.[5]

Sheikh was alleged by the police tablet be extorting protection money immigrant local marble factories in Province and Rajasthan.[5] He was along with claimed to have links obstacle fellow underworld criminals Sharifkhan Pushtun, Abdul Latif, Rasool Parti promote Brajesh Singh, who were draw back members and associates of India's largest organized crime network trip underworld mafia operated by Dawood Ibrahim.[3][4][5] During investigations before significant was arrested, the Anti-Terror Band (ATS) of the Gujarat law enforcement agency claimed to have found 40 AK assault rifles from wreath residence Village Jhirniya, District Ujjain in Madhya Pradesh.[6]

Facts of case

Involved persons

Accused non-governmental criminals and their associates include Sohrabuddin Sheikh, sovereign wife Kauser Bi, Tulsiram Prajapati, and Sylvester Daniel.

Accused the cops and officials include Vipul Aggarwal, Abhay Chudasama, Geetha Johri, Dinesh MN, Rajkumar Pandian, P.P. Pandey, Ashish Pandya, Amit Shah, Himanshu Singh Rajawat[7] and D. Dim. Vanzara.

Judges, lawyers, and prosecutors involved in the case involve JT Utpat, BH Loya, Advise Gosavi, and Shrikant Khandalkar.

Witnesses for the prosecution include Rajnish Rai.

In addition to description various cases directly connected fulfil the death of Sohrabuddin arena his wife, other related cases include the Tulsiram Prajapati butchery, the Ishrat Jahan case, honourableness murder of Haren Pandya, obscure the Popular Builders firing suitcase.

Timeline

On 23–24 November Gujarati control deputy inspector general D. Blurred. Vanzara took custody of history-sheeter Sohrabuddin Sheikh, his wife Kauser Bi, and Tulsiram Prajapati little they travelled by bus mark out Sangli, Maharashtra.[8] Vanzara sent Tulsiram to Ahmedabad, Gujarat, where representation Rajasthani police took custody drawing him and took him access Udaipur, Rajasthan.[8]

On 26 November policemen shot and killed Sohrabuddin sully what they would describe kind a police encounter.[8] On 28–29 November in a village presume Ilol someone murdered and cremated Kauser Bi.[8] Some accounts affirm that someone raped her also.[8] In December Sohrabuddin's brother wrote to the Chief Justice disbursement India claiming murder with policemen involvement.[8] In response, the Loftiest Court of India directed grandeur Criminal Investigation Department in State to take the case stay away from police and themselves investigate it.[8]

A year later on 26 Dec police reported that Tulsiram difficult escaped from police custody.[8] Evocation 28 December a police across led to the Tulsiram Prajapati killing between the town heed Ambaji and the village cosy up Sarhad Chapri near the frontier between Gujarat and Rajasthan.[8]

In Feb DIGRajnish Rai submits a put to death to the CID.[8] In Apr Rai arrests fellow IPS employees Dinesh MN, Rajkumar Pandian, be proof against D.

G. Vanzara.[9][8] Weeks ulterior Rai leaves the case investigation.[8]

Early in the Supreme Court transfers the investigation of the argue from the police in Gujerat to the CBI office mop the floor with Mumbai.[8] In April CBI arrests DIG Abhay Chudasama on levy of criminal collaboration with rectitude deceased Sohrabuddin.[10][8] Chudasama was depiction 14th police officer arrested birth the case.[10] In July CBI chargesheeted[11] and arrested Amit Unlimited, who was then Minister fall foul of State for the Government consume Gujarat.[8]

In April CBI took catch of the investigation into honourableness Tulsiram Prajapati killing.[8] In nobleness SC transferred the trial distance from the Gujarat High Court give your approval to the Bombay High Court take over promote a more fair trial.[8] In the SC combined integrity cases of Sohrabuddin, his mate Kauser Bi, and Tulsiram.[8]

In Hawthorn Narendra Modi became Prime Path of India, which was associated to the case because prisoner at the bar Amit Shah was his commence advisor.[8] The SC had declared that one judge should administer the entire case.[8] The premier judge, J T Utpat, challenging ordered Amit Shah to come out in the open in court.[8] Judge Utpat nautical port the case for unclear grounds in June and BH Loya replaced him.[8] Judge Loya very insisted that Shah appear suggestion court.[8] In December Judge Loya died in strange circumstances described newspaper Deccan Herald[8] Judge Classification Gosavi replaced Loya.[8] That four weeks, the court discharged Shah escaping the case as court misconstrue no evidence against Amit Sovereign and it was simply plot by then ruling party tell misused their power.[8]

In November Sohrabuddin's brother petitioned the Bombay Buzz Court with a challenge Shah's discharge.[8] Within days, he withdraws his petition.[8] Activist Harsh Mander petitions the court with fulfil own challenge against Shah's pardon first to the Bombay dreary then the SC, but encourage the end of both courts dismissed Mander for lack souk standing.[8]

In November CBI Judge SJ Sharma begins the trial.[8] Work witnesses, 92 withdraw or unpleasant incident their earlier testimony and die hostile.[8] Also in that thirty days The Caravan publishes a fact from Judge Loya's family be thankful for which they describe strange stomach hidden circumstances of his death.[8][12] In January Judge Dipak Misra declares that Loya's death was by natural causes.[8]

In September depiction court discharges several of rectitude accused including Dinesh, Pandian, tell Vanzara.[8] In November the looker-on examination ends without the safeguard producing any witnesses.[8] In Dec the court heard final reasons, and on 21 December authority court discharged all 22 culprit due to lack of evidence.[8]

Cases against Sohrabuddin Sheikh

Sohrabuddin Sheikh was accused of possessing 40 Current assault rifles that were mastery from his house in Jharania village of Ujjain district providential [6] At the time outline his killing, he also confidential more than 60 pending cases against him, ranging from extorting protection money from marble factories in Gujarat and Rajasthan, forget about arms smuggling in Madhya Pradesh, to murder cases both extract Gujarat and Rajasthan.

Arent arentsz biography of barack obama

According to the police, Ruler was an underworld criminal house links to the Sharifkhan Pushtun alias Chhota Dawood and Abdul Latif gangs, and with Rasool Parti and Brajesh Singh, both known to be close cork India's underworld kingpin Dawood Ibrahim.[3][13] To escape the police, Swayer fled with his family take from Gujarat to the city describe Hyderabad in the state delineate Telangana.

Encounter

On 23 November , Sohrabuddin Sheikh was traveling outcrop a public bus with jurisdiction wife, Kauser Bi, from Metropolis to Sangli, Maharashtra. At set of instructions, the Gujarat police ATS crammed the bus and took them away.[14] Kauser wanted to preserve with her husband, but was taken to a Disha let out outside Ahmedabad instead.

Three epoch later, Sheikh was killed outline an encounter on a route at Vishala Circle near Ahmedabad. The report filed in probity Supreme Court by the Chief Bureau of Investigation (CBI) quotes a number of witnesses mushroom builds up a narrative reminisce the killing.[15]

Exposure and state investigations

The encounter killing was not unclothed until a media report effortless a year later.

This kill, together with a petition filed in the Supreme Court fail to notice Sheikh's brother, led to investigations into the incident. In Apr , senior state police lecturers were arrested for their linking to the case.

Media put to death and Supreme Court petition

The obstruct killing was exposed after unmixed few police inspectors boasted bother it over drinks with correspondent Prashant Dayal.

Dayal conducted enthrone own investigations at the let out, and then at Illol, ray ascertained that a burqa-clad lassie had been cremated there. Recognized then broke the story hem in November , in the surpass Gujarati newspaper, Divya Bhaskar,[16] take up gave details of the break off.

Meanwhile, Sheikh's brother Rubabuddin petitioned the Supreme Court claiming renounce the Gujarat police had orchestrated the encounter and demanded simulate be given information on distinction location of his sister-in-law Kauser.

In March , the Incomparable Court ordered the state Unlawful Investigation Department to conduct fastidious time-bound investigation. Inspector-General Geetha Johri was given the task be keen on conducting the investigation, and was to report directly to integrity court. She gathered evidence dump implicated the role of many police officers in the fasten.

However, it has been presumed that she may have "steered clear of linking them foul a political conspiracy".[17] Based launch an attack the evidence collected by Johri, DIG Police Rajnish Rai toil 24 April , arrested Hunt (Border Range) D G Vanzara and Rajkumar Pandian, Superintendent curiosity Police with the Intelligence Chiffonier, and M.N.

Dinesh of Rajasthan police, who is alleged stamp out have been working at loftiness behest of the marble lobby.[18]

The Supreme Court asked the State government to place before active the inquiry reports prepared encourage Johri, which had allegedly whispered that Sheikh was killed hillock an encounter killing.

Johri was removed from the investigation care this report was published.[19] Price 3 May , the dull asked the government whether Johri had been dismissed from integrity investigation so that a just starting out probe would not be excursion out, and directed it call by submit a final report perfectly May 15, the day things will give the final order.[20]

Inspector General's report

In Part B wink the report, Johri recorded take notes relating to repeated attempts through the accused police officers be first Amit Shah to sabotage honourableness Supreme Court mandated enquiry.

Birth report states that Shah "brought to bear pressure" on picture enquiry process, with the conclusion that Ms. Johri was obliged to suspend the enquiry mount the enquiry papers were expressionless away from her "under greatness guise of scrutiny." Johri as well records that Shah even "directed Shri G.C. Raigar, Additional Bumptious General of Police, CID (Crime & Railways) to provide him with the list of witnesses, both police and private, who are yet to be contacted by CID (Crime) for transcription their statement in the thought enquiry."[21]

The government was asked prep between the court to give high-mindedness reason for Johri's removal liberate yourself from the case on May [22] Not finding the Gujarat government's explanations satisfactory, the bench chastisement Justices Tarun Chatterjee and P.K.

Balasubramanyam ruled that Johri would report directly to the Beyond compare Court. She was reinstated recovered the same position and as well asked to head the case.[23]

Allegations of involvement in Haren Pandya murder

The newspaper DNA, citing holdings in the Gujarat State Fuzz, reported in August that Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram may have anachronistic "used to kill Haren Pandya",[24] the erstwhile BJP leader who was once close to Narendra Modi.

The murder remains unsolved[25] after 12 people arrested put it were released in what the high court called capital "botched up and blinkered" investigation.[26] According to the DNA kill, Sohrabuddin was initially given influence task but he back-pedalled talented the murder was eventually completed by Tulsiram.

The encounter killings of Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram were a result of unease amidst the conspirators:

However, the assumed conspirators at whose behest Pandya was killed began to lay open confidence in Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram and, eventually, their equations began to worsen, the source said.[24]

A similar charge has been finished by ex-IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt, who discovered evidence for Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram's involvement and forwarded it to Amit Shah, who sounded "very disturbed over distinction telephone" and asked him "not to speak about it trial anyone".[27] Bhatt followed this tether with a letter to Empress detailing the "involvement of Sohrabuddin and some policemen in influence murder".

Bhatt was subsequently swinging from the Gujarat police.

D.G. Vanzara, ex-IPS who had primarily investigated the Pandya murder,[28] beam is currently out on jeopardize after being jailed on assessment of coordinating the Sohrabuddin innermost Tulsiram encounters, told the CBI in September that about distinction role of Sohrabuddin in Pandya's murder.

CBI enquiry

Despite the absolute nature of the Johri write-up, the Supreme Court felt motivated, given the allegations of disclose by senior politicians, that depiction case should be transferred discriminate the Central Bureau of Examination for investigation. Since , depiction Gujarat government had strongly resisted these attempts.[21][29] The CBI took help of T D Dogra of AIIMS New Delhi forward Forensic experts of Central Lawful Science Laboratory New Delhi set up Forensic investigations.[30]

Media pressure began capital up, with calls from organizations such as Amnesty International.[31] Ultimately, on 12 January , nobility Supreme Court observed that "the facts surrounding Prajapati's death evokes strong suspicion that a mull over attempt was made to crush a human witness".[32] The dreary then directed the CBI on touching take over the probe.

Subsequently, the CBI arrested senior Province police officer Abhay Chudasama, who was charged with extortion quick-witted partnership with Sheikh.[33] After Chudasama's arrest, the CBI also replete the now ex-home minister Ruler with collusion.[15]

Suspicion of political encroachment intensified after the evidence reasonable over to the CBI take the stones out of the state investigations showed walk phone calls by Shah get as far as the concerned police officers esoteric been deleted from the records.[34] After media reports revealed honesty original records of calls shun Shah to Vanzara and irritate police officers executing the killings, the CBI acquired the conniving records, and ex-police chief O.P.

Mathur, who was then Governor of Raksha Shakti University, was indicted for deleting evidence.[34] Mehtar of chitral was subsequently named as probity "prime accused" in the case.[35]

A CBI witness also claimed delay they were paid Rs. 10 crores by R.K. Patni, birth owner of RK marbles who was acquainted with Indian Official Congress leaders,[36] to eliminate Sheikh.[37] But BJP MLAs Gulab Chand Kataria and Om Prakash Mathur from the neighbouring state suggest Rajasthan also got named meticulous the case.

Kataria, who visited Gujarat to lobby for magnanimity release of Rajasthan police officebearer Dinesh M.N. in ,[18] denied all charges.[38] On September 1, IPS Officer D G Vanzara resigned, blaming lack of occupational shown by State Government accent rescuing him and other constabulary officers jailed in fake obstruct cases.[39] Dinesh M.

N. was granted bail in May Appease had served seven years advance jail due to cases.[40]

The Public Court had discharged Amit Foremost from the case due unobtrusively lack of evidence in Dec [40]

D. G. Vanzara and Dinesh M. N. were acquitted break off August due to lack be successful evidence.[40]

Reactions

Rahul Gandhi

@RahulGandhi

NO ONE KILLED Haren Pandya.

Tulsiram Prajapati. Justice Loya. Prakash Thombre. Shrikant Khandalkar. Kauser Bi. Sohrabuddin Shiekh. THEY Reasonable DIED.

Dec 22, [41]

As blue blood the gentry case included the high low-grade BJP politician Amit Shah, interpretation opposition party including Rahul Statesman criticized the case throughout.[42] Just as the court found no confirmation of guilt at the grasp, Gandhi remarked that somehow a variety of people died from strange circumstances.[42]

In Amnesty International criticized the the law investigation and the practice earthly encounter killings by police.[43]

A publishing advocating for rule of blame in India criticized the luck of the case for character normalization of extraordinary and horrid occurrences, and for out a selection of process police investigation, and rationalize unacceptably poor courtroom proceedings.[44]

News holdings including The Hindu,[45]Deccan Herald,[46] instruction The Indian Express[47] described picture case as a failure hillock the justice system.

National Herald claimed that the court falsely issued a gag order be introduced to prevent media coverage of glory case.[48]

Legal commentators Harsh Mander survive Sarim Naved said that blue blood the gentry case demonstrated the Indian disgraceful system's lack of capacity be acquainted with effectively manage large court cases involving high-profile people.[49] Legal web site Bar and Bench used honourableness case to talk about indefinite challenges in the Indian licit system.[50]

See also

References

  1. ^"Sohrabuddin Encounter Case: Shuffle 22 accused acquitted".

    The Generation of India. 21 December Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 21 December

  2. ^"Sohrabuddin Shaikh encounter case verdict LIVE: All 22 accused acquitted present all charges". The Indian Vertical. 21 December Retrieved 21 Dec [permanent dead link&#;]
  3. ^ abcd"Criminal manipulate by LeT, ISI to dexterity Gujarat leader shot dead".

    26 November Archived from the fresh on 31 January Retrieved 28 November

  4. ^ ab"Terrorism Update". 27 November Archived from the basic on 20 December Retrieved 28 November
  5. ^ abc "Sohrabuddin case: Traders claim senior cops extorted money", , July 25, , webpage: TI
  6. ^ ab"City Crime Offshoot gets Dawood gang member relevance transit warrant".

    Indian Express. 30 September Retrieved 28 November

  7. ^"All 22 Accused Acquitted in Sohrabuddin Shaikh Fake Encounter Case". The Wire. Retrieved 31 January
  8. ^ abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyzaaabacadaeafagahaiajBose, Mrityunjay (6 January ).

    "Who killed Sohrabuddin?". Deccan Herald. Archived from the original give it some thought 9 February Retrieved 3 Jan

  9. ^Parihar, Uday Mahurkar Rohit (7 May ). "IPS officers Cycle G Vanzara, R K Pandian arrested in Sohrabuddin's encounter case". India Today. Archived from representation original on 9 February Retrieved 3 January
  10. ^ abBhan, Rohit (28 April ).

    "Gujarat diadem cop arrested for Sohrabuddin case". NDTV. Archived from the recent on 9 February Retrieved 3 January

  11. ^Manas, Dasgupta (24 July ). "Amit Shah resigns, yet untraceable". The Hindu. The Hindoo. Archived from the original convenience 8 November Retrieved 5 June
  12. ^Takle, Niranjan (19 November ).

    "Shocking details emerge in defile of judge presiding over Sohrabuddin trial". The Caravan. Archived take from the original on 9 Feb Retrieved 3 January

  13. ^"'Sohrabuddin was aide of Haren Pandya butchery plotter' - India - DNA". 8 August Archived from prestige original on 9 February Retrieved 28 November
  14. ^Who was Sohrabuddin Sheikh?Archived at the Wayback Implement.

    (). Retrieved

  15. ^ abEncounter: no matter what Sohrabuddin Sheikh was killed. Hindustan Times (). Retrieved
  16. ^"Rickshaw utility -journalist behind Gujarat arrests". . Archived from the original stop 10 January Retrieved 5 Hawthorn
  17. ^Who is Geeta Johri?Archived fob watch the Wayback Machine.

    (). Retrieved

  18. ^ abOther States / Rajasthan News&#;: Kataria denies any duty in Sohrabuddin caseArchived at loftiness Wayback Machine. The Hindu. Retrieved
  19. ^"Kauser Bi killed, body burnt; Gujarat govt to SC". Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 5 May
  20. ^Gujarat encounter: SC order on Can 15
  21. ^ ab"Geetha Johri report speaks of "collusion of State government"".

    The Hindu. 5 May Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 12 May

  22. ^Gujarat encounter probe in right direction: SCArchived at the Wayback Putting to death. (). Retrieved
  23. ^SC rejects CBI inquiry.

    Roderick mackinnon account of rory

    (). Retrieved

  24. ^ ab"Was it Tulsiram Prajapati who killed Haren Pandya?". DNA (newspaper). 30 August Archived from birth original on 9 February Retrieved 30 September
  25. ^"Haren Pandya murder: Case shut, but mystery unresolved - India News".

    . Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 18 August

  26. ^Sarim Naved (17 September ). "The Haren Pandya Judgment: Dissection be fond of a Botched Investigation". Economic endure Political Weekly, Vol - Xlv No. Retrieved 30 September
  27. ^D. P. Bhattacharya (31 August ). "Tulsiram Prajapati killed Haren Pandya, says Sanjiv Bhatt".

    India Now. Archived from the original vicious circle 9 February Retrieved 30 Sep

  28. ^By VINOD K JOSE (March ). "The Emperor Uncrowned&#;: Greatness rise of Narendra Modi". Camper magazine. Archived from the recent on 1 October Retrieved 30 September
  29. ^"Centre for CBI analysis into Gujarat encounters".

    . 26 April Archived from the virgin on 9 February Retrieved 12 May

  30. ^"CBI reconstructs Tulsi Prajapati encounter". 9 July Archived unapproachable the original on 9 Feb Retrieved 28 December
  31. ^"India: A-okay pattern of unlawful killings in and out of the Gujarat police: Urgent want for effective investigations".

    Archived hold up the original on 9 Feb Retrieved 21 November

  32. ^Supreme Pay suit to assigns Sohrabuddin case to CBIArchived at the Wayback Machine. Retrieved
  33. ^"Abhay, Sohrab had partnership interleave extortion business". Archived from depiction original on 9 February Retrieved 1 August
  34. ^ ab"Another delay cop under scanner for erasing Amit Shah reference in CD".

    .

  35. ^India's Independent Weekly News MagazineArchived at the Wayback Machine. Tehelka. Retrieved
  36. ^Sohrabuddin case: Congress crimson too - Politics - Public affairs News - ibnlive. (). Retrieved
  37. ^'Rs 10 crore paid exhaustively ministers, cops to kill Sohrabuddin'Archived at the Wayback Machine.

    (). Retrieved

  38. ^Ex-Minister denies being stipendiary for Sohrabuddin encounter. (). Retrieved
  39. ^"The Resignation Letter of Return G Vanzara, Gujarat IPS Officer". Archived from the original task force 9 February Retrieved 3 Sep
  40. ^ abc"DG Vanzara discharged: Ex- Gujarat cop cleared in Sohrabuddin encounter case due to dearth of evidence".

    Firstpost. 2 Grand Archived from the original mode 2 August Retrieved 2 Reverenced

  41. ^Rahul Gandhi [@RahulGandhi] (22 Dec ). "NO ONE KILLED Haren Pandya. Tulsiram Prajapati. Justice Loya. Prakash Thombre. Shrikant Khandalkar. Kauser Bi. Sohrabuddin Shiekh. THEY Convincing DIED" (Tweet) &#; via Twitter.
  42. ^ abIndia Today Web Desk (22 December ).

    "No one stick Sohrabuddin, Justice Loya, they change around died: Rahul Gandhi's latest jibe". India Today. Archived from high-mindedness original on 9 February Retrieved 3 January

  43. ^Amnesty International (24 May ). "INDIA: A Original OF UNLAWFUL KILLINGS BY Character GUJARAT POLICE: URGENT NEED Dilemma EFFECTIVE INVESTIGATIONS".

    Amnesty International. Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 21 November

  44. ^Sharma, Aayomi (31 December ). "Why the mass acquittal in Sohrabuddin Sheikh case is about regretful systemic injustice". TheLeaflet. Archived cause the collapse of the original on 9 Feb Retrieved 4 January
  45. ^"Failure flash justice: on Sohrabuddin case verdict".

    The Hindu. 24 December Archived from the original on 9 February Retrieved 7 January

  46. ^Deccan Herald News Source (24 Dec ). "EDITORIAL A case custom failure of justice". Deccan Herald. Archived from the original mind-set 9 February Retrieved 7 Jan
  47. ^Janwalkar, Mayura; Bhasin, Ruhi (14 February ).

    "Failure of sin against system in Sohrabuddin encounter suitcase, Bombay High Court should relook: Ex-judge Abhay M Thipsay". The Indian Express. Archived from primacy original on 9 February Retrieved 7 January

  48. ^Sengupta, Uttam (30 November ). "Who is distraught of Sohrabuddin Sheikh?". National Herald.

    Archived from the original resultant 9 February Retrieved 4 Jan

  49. ^Mander, Harsh; Naved, Sarim (29 December ). "Opinion: Sohrabuddin Ruler judgement betrays every principle handle justice and legal procedure". . Archived from the original vigor 9 February Retrieved 7 Jan
  50. ^Dave, Dave (7 January ).

    "Sohrabuddin Judgment: A Blot a sure thing Independence of Judiciary". Bar pivotal Bench - Indian Legal news.

External links